NEWS & REPORTS

Trucking insurance prices at all-time high

Oct 25, 2025 | Articles

Overdrive Staff

  • Watchers credited several factors — from inflation in equipment and medical costs to nuclear verdicts and pressure to settle suits — for an unprecedented rise in trucking insurance premiums.
  • The FTC has concluded an investigation into truck OEMs’ Clean Truck Partnership with CARB; Nebraska’s AG dropped a suit challenging the partnership.
  • Truck and trailer parts distributor TruckPro recently donated $115,000 to four charity organizations that it supports.

Numbers from the Bureau of Labor Statistics show insurance premiums for the commercial vehicle sector are at all-time highs — likely no surprise to owner-operators and small fleets.

Overdrive’s sister dealer publication Truck, Parts, Service recently offered an update on how soaring insurance costs are affecting truckers’ equipment purchases. In reporting from TPS’s Beth Colvin, analyst Avery Vise of FTR Transportation Intelligence credited several factors, including inflation, for rising trucking insurance costs.

“If you think about even liability insurance, hospitalization costs have gone up, the cost of vehicles have gone up,” Vise said. “If you’re in an accident and you damage a car or total a car, the cost of that goes up. The lost income goes up. You have the nuclear verdict issue, which is kind of its own issue, but you also have the fact that the actual cost to replace things to compensate has gone up.”

Insurance underwriters are also anticipating further inflation as a result of any future tariffs on trucks and truck parts, particularly from Mexico and Canada, which has led to some insurance increases since January, Colvin reported.

“They are expecting the spare parts to go up a lot because of the embedded tariffs,” even if those tariffs aren’t active yet, and even if not every replacement part is exposed, said Thom Albrecht, CFO and chief revenue officer for Reliance Partners.

Beyond nuclear verdicts, litigation in general is also spiking insurance costs, as verdicts and case settlements below “nuclear” levels are still higher than they have been in the past.

“Maybe five to seven years ago, a broken leg and lost wages might have represented $80,000 to $100,000,” Albrecht said. “We see the same claim settle [today] for $300,000 to $400,000.”

As a result, owner-operators and fleets are holding onto equipment longer than they maybe traditionally would have.

As reported earlier this year, there are ways for owners to ensure they are making the best case for themselves when it comes time for their insurance renewal.

About the Author

NEWS & REPORTS

Trucking Combats Soaring Nuclear Verdicts and Insurance Costs

Experts Recommend Mitigation Strategies Like Ensuring Safety of Equipment, Smart Insurance Policies, Relationships With Attorneys Connor D. Wolf SAN DIEGO — The trucking industry has been facing surging unfavorable verdicts and insurance costs as biases and policies...

CVSA Annual Conference Recap

North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria The following amendments were suggested for the North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria (OOSC). They were presented to Class I Members for a vote. The approved changes will be incorporated into next year’s...

Drivers Most Fret About Wages Not Keeping Up With Inflation

Truck Parking Slips to No. 2 Spot in Annual ATRI Survey Keiron Greenhalgh Adequate compensation is the top concern among professional drivers in 2025, according to the American Transportation Research Institute’s annual survey of trucking industry participants. Driver...

A truck crash study redo

Mark Schremmer About two decades ago, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration attempted to study the causes of large truck crashes. It’s fair to say that the truck crash study was a disappointment. As Land Line Managing Editor Jami Jones pointed out in a...

Trucking lawsuits driving up food prices, killing jobs

Tyson Fisher An increase in lawsuits and nuclear verdicts has been a growing problem for the trucking industry. However, researchers found that sweeping tort reform would greatly benefit all Americans, including addressing one of their main concerns: food prices. Tort...

CATEGORIES