A Perspective from Roadside by Jake Elovirta, Director of Enforcement Programs, Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA)
Introduction
Commercial Motor Vehicle (CMV) enforcement agencies operate on a straightforward premise that a fully loaded tractor-trailer weighing up to 80,000 lbs. shares the same roadways as passenger cars, motorcycles, and school buses. The margin for error when something goes wrong is virtually nonexistent. Enforcement exists to ensure that margin is never tested unnecessarily.
Every day, enforcement officers conduct roadside inspections, traffic enforcement stops, size and weight checks, and compliance reviews under the authority of federal and state regulations administered through the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). The goal is not to burden commerce; it is to prevent the kind of serious or fatal crashes that too often occur due to ignored maintenance, falsified records, or impaired operators. This article presents the enforcement community’s perspective on why that mission is so essential, and why prosecution of serious violations is the necessary partner to the work done by roadside enforcement.
The Regulatory Framework That Guides Enforcement
CMV enforcement in the United States operates within a well-established federal framework. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSRs), codified under 49 C.F.R. Parts 300–399, govern virtually every aspect of commercial motor vehicle operations from driver qualifications and hours of service to vehicle maintenance and hazardous materials transport. The FMCSA was officially established under the Motor Carrier Safety Improvement Act of 1999 (Pub. L. 106–159), which holds primary federal authority for CMV safety oversight.
At the state level, enforcement agencies have adopted the federal regulations under compatible state regulations and participate as members of the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA), which standardized inspection procedures and out-of-service criteria across jurisdictions. This coordination ensures that a vehicle placed out of service in one state cannot simply cross a state line to continue operating illegally. For enforcement officers, this framework is not bureaucratic red tape; it is the legal architecture that gives their work meaning and consequence.
What CMV Enforcement Officers Actually Do
CMV enforcement is not simply issuing citations at weigh stations. Officers are trained to identify safety violations at roadside that can turn an 80,000-pound vehicle into a hazard to the motoring public.
Roadside Inspections
Officers are trained to identify safety violations at roadside that can turn an 80,000 pound vehicle into a hazard to the motoring public. Roadside inspections follow CVSA’s standardized protocols and can range from a Level I inspection—with a comprehensive 37-step examination of both driver and vehicle—to more targeted checks based on observed behavior or data-driven risk scoring.
Under 49 C.F.R. Part 396, carriers are required to maintain vehicles in safe operating condition, and inspections verify that those obligations are being met. Officers routinely find brake systems exceeding the adjustment limits set in 49 C.F.R. Part 393, defective tires, inoperable lighting, and compromised coupling devices. These are not minor inconveniences; brake defects alone can extend stopping distances significantly, with potentially fatal consequences at highway speeds.
When a violation meets an out-of-service threshold as defined by CVSA Out-of-Service (OOS) Criteria, officers have the authority to remove the driver or vehicle from operation immediately. During CVSA’s 2025 International Roadcheck event, vehicles inspected had an OOS rate of 18.1%,1 meaning that nearly one in every five trucks inspected was placed out of service for critical violations. Each of those removals represents a potential crash that did not occur.
Hours-of-Service and Electronic Logging Device
Enforcement (ELD) Driver fatigue is among the most well-documented contributors to CMV crashes. Research from FMCSA has found that fatigue is a factor in a significant percentage of large-truck crashes. 2,3 Hours-of-service (HOS) regulations under 49 C.F.R. Part 395 set strict limits on driving time and mandatory rest requirements precisely because the consequences of fatigued commercial driving are so severe.
Since the ELD mandate took full effect under 49 C.F.R. § 395.8(a)(1), enforcement officers have a more reliable tool for verifying compliance. But ELD data is only useful if violations are acted upon. When officers discover falsified supporting documents, manipulated ELD data, or drivers operating far beyond legal hours, those findings deserve prosecutorial attention proportionate to the danger involved. A driver who has been behind the wheel for 20 hours is not a minor regulatory offender; that driver presents a risk comparable to an impaired operator.4
Drug and Alcohol Enforcement
Commercial drivers are subject to a 0.04% blood alcohol concentration (BAC) limit under 49 C.F.R. § 392.5, half the standard 0.08% limit applicable to non commercial drivers. This stricter standard reflects the obvious reality that the consequences of impaired operation scale with vehicle size.5 The FMCSA’s drug and alcohol testing program, governed by 49 C.F.R. Part 382, requires pre-employment, random, post-accident, and reasonable suspicion testing.
Officers trained in impaired driving detection encounter commercial drivers who are operating under the influence of alcohol, controlled substances, or prescription medications that impair their ability to safely control a large vehicle. Prosecution of cases sends a message that the commercial transportation industry demands, and the public deserves.
Hazardous Materials Compliance
The transportation of hazardous materials is regulated under the Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMR) at 49 C.F.R. Parts 100–185, administered jointly by the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) and FMCSA. Officers enforcing these regulations are not checking paperwork as a mere formality. They are verifying that explosives, flammable liquids, toxic substances, and radioactive materials are properly packaged, labeled, placarded, and routed because the consequence of failure can be a community-level disaster.
Hazardous materials violations are among the most serious that enforcement officers encounter. A single incident involving improperly secured or documented hazardous cargo can result in mass casualties, environmental contamination requiring years of remediation, and the displacement of entire neighborhoods. 6 These violations warrant aggressive prosecution.
1 CVSA 2025 International Roadcheck Results Press Release, CVSA Releases 2025 International Roadcheck Results, CVSA–Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance. B
2 Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. (2006). Large Truck Crash Causation Study. U.S. Department of Transportation.
3 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2016). Commercial Motor Vehicle Driver Fatigue, Long-Term Health, and Highway Safety: Research Needs. National Academies Press.
4 Dawson, D., & Reid, K. (1997). Fatigue, alcohol and performance impairment. Nature, 388(6639), 235.
5 A Review of Alcohol-Impaired Driving: The Role of Blood Alcohol Concentration and Complexity of the Driving Task, Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 58, No. 5 (Sept. 2013). Summary: A review of the scientific literature indicates that a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.05% impairs the faculties necessary for safe motor vehicle operation.
6 National Transportation Safety Board. (2025). Cargo Tank Combination Vehicle Roadway Departure, Rollover, and Release of Anhydrous Ammonia, Teutopolis, Illinois [Final report]
Another good article from OverDrive Magazine on ELD Fraud; https://www.overdriveonline.com/overdrive-extra/article/15975351/how-1m-eld-fraudsters-broke-trucking-and-how-to-save-it
Check out this investigative news report from OverDrive Magazine;
https://www.overdriveonline.com/electronic-logging-devices/article/16050311/fmcsa-will-hold-violators-fully-accountable-for-eld-fraud.
Could not have state the case any better myself. It’s beyond time to clean up the violators in our industry.
Scopelitis
For years, many parts of the trucking ecosystem operated on what was effectively an honor system. We trusted training providers to properly train drivers. We trusted states to issue credentials correctly. We trusted brokers, carriers, and drivers to maintain accurate records. Increasingly, federal and state agencies are concluding that trust alone is not enough. Verification is becoming the new standard—and the change is visible everywhere.
The End of the Honor System
Take Entry-Level Driver Training (ELDT) as an example. When the Training Provider Registry was established, participation relied heavily on self-certification. That approach is now under intense scrutiny. Nearly 10,000 training-provider locations have been removed from the registry, hundreds more remain under review, and federal investigators are examining dozens of CDL schools for allegedly falsified records. At the same time, FMCSA is weighing a provider-certification rulemaking that could move the industry away from pure self-certification toward ongoing verification and oversight. The message is clear: regulators no longer provide assurances that training occurred. They want proof.
The enforcement posture escalated sharply in late August, when U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin joined the White House Task Force to Eliminate Fraud and top U.S. Attorneys to
The CDL Squeeze
The same trend is occurring in the CDL credentialing space. The new non-domiciled CDL rule significantly narrows eligibility, potentially affecting a substantial portion of the current non-domiciled driver population as licenses expire. Meanwhile, states continue to examine improperly issued licenses and English Language Proficiency (ELP) requirements, with ELP now emerging as a leading driver of out-of-service conditions. The August interagency effort underscored how quickly this can move, and in nearly every case, the burden of ensuring compliance ultimately falls on the motor carrier.
Brokers After Montgomery
Brokers are facing similar pressure. The Supreme Court’s decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II fundamentally changed the conversation around carrier selection. The ruling did not automatically make brokers liable for every crash involving a motor carrier, but it removed a major defense by allowing state-law negligent-hiring claims to proceed. In addition, FMCSA is tightening its focus on broker qualifications and has a broker transparency rule on its Docket for action. The practical implication is significant: brokers must now be prepared to demonstrate that they exercised reasonable care when selecting carriers. Documentation, audit trails, and verification records suddenly matter more than ever.
The Carrier and the Digital Threat
We see the same pattern in cargo theft. Modern cargo theft increasingly involves identity manipulation, fictitious pickups, double-brokering, stolen credentials, and what some investigators call the “Trojan-horse driver” problem, in which bad actors infiltrate legitimate companies. Cargo theft has evolved from a physical security issue into an identity verification challenge. Knowing that a carrier exists is no longer enough. Knowing who is operating under that authority is becoming equally important.
Even electronic logging devices tell the same story. FMCSA and CVSA have intensified their focus on ELD tampering and record falsification. Enforcement officials are increasingly comparing log records with supporting documentation to identify discrepancies. The fundamental question is no longer whether data exists, but whether the data can be trusted.
The Throughline: One Problem, Many Faces
Viewed together, these developments reveal an important throughline. Cargo theft, broker liability, CDL fraud, ELDT oversight, ELD tampering, ELP enforcement, and registration modernization may appear to be separate issues. They are not. At their core, they are all verification challenges—all attempts to close gaps in credentialing and identity management across the motor carrier, the broker, and the driver.
The industry is moving toward a world where verification is continuous rather than periodic. Regulators want better visibility. Courts want better documentation. Insurers want evidence of reasonable care. Technology providers are building tools designed around verification, documentation, monitoring, and risk scoring precisely because those capabilities solve the underlying problem enforcement agencies are trying to address.
The Bottom Line: Get Your Processes and Paperwork in Order
For motor carriers, the response should be straightforward: get your house in order. Review your driver-qualification files. Verify the status of your ELDT providers. Confirm the validity of driver credentials. Audit your supporting records. Reexamine onboarding processes. Evaluate how frequently you verify carriers, brokers, and drivers, and ensure documentation is accurate, up to date, and readily accessible. What was once considered administrative housekeeping is fast becoming a frontline risk-management strategy.
In other words: trust but verify. The regulators certainly are.
Charlotte, NC – Today, the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), the trucking industry’s not-for-profit research organization, released its 22nd annual Top Industry Issues report that identifies the trucking industry’s leading issues. This year’s list includes Fuel Prices, Lawsuit Abuse Reform, CSA and Insurance Cost/Availability. Two issues that debuted on the 2025 list have remained top 10 concerns again this year: Artificial Intelligence in Trucking and Diesel Emissions Regulations.
“Just as we started to see some positive signs in the freight economy, the cost of diesel topped $6.50 per gallon,” said Ben Banks, TCW President. “With operating costs continuing to climb overall, this spike in fuel costs is particularly painful for small- to mid-size fleets. ATRI’s annual analysis is so essential for trucking to not only quantify the issues, but more importantly, to understand what we can collectively do as an industry to address each.”
After holding on to the number one spot on the list for three years in a row, the Economy dropped down to #6 overall, reflecting some cautious optimism on the part of motor carriers. Given some positive signs in the economy, this year’s list saw workforce issues come back into the top 10, with the Driver Shortage at #5 and Driver Retention at #10. Driver Compensation remained a top 10 issue, ranking 9th overall.
More than 48 percent of the survey respondents were motor carrier executives and personnel, truck drivers represented 26 percent, with the remaining 26 percent made up of other freight stakeholders. Among truck driver respondents – both owner-operators and company drivers – Fuel Prices, Truck Parking and Driver Compensation were the top three concerns, while motor carriers ranked Lawsuit Abuse Reform, Fuel Prices and the Driver Shortage as their top three concerns.
Nearly 3,100 trucking industry stakeholders participated in this year’s survey. Respondents included motor carriers, truck drivers, industry suppliers, driver trainers and law enforcement, among other groups. This year’s report also includes an analysis of the top concerns among law enforcement personnel, whose top-ranked issue was Electronic Logging Device Fraud. Finally, states that generated adequate response rates received state-specific TII analyses.
The complete results of the annual survey were released as part of 2026 American Trucking Associations Management Conference and Exhibition. The full report can be found on ATRI’s website here.
Scopelitis
Here’s a question worth 60 seconds of your time: if you had to name the handful of crash types most likely to hurt someone in your operation, could you? Most of us think crashes are random bolts of lightning. They’re not. When you dig into the national data, the same short list of scenarios shows up again and again, which is actually good news because a predictable problem is a manageable one.
We recently built a large truck and bus pre-crash scenario typology, adapting the same methodology the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) uses for passenger vehicles. The headline finding is simple: truck and bus crashes types cluster into a small number of “families.” Nail down those families, and you’ve addressed the lion’s share of your risk.
What the data actually says
In 2022, there were roughly 503,000 police-reported crashes involving large trucks, including 5,279 fatal crashes, according to FMCSA’s Large Truck and Bus Crash Facts 2022. These figures aren’t extrapolated from the passenger-vehicle work — they come straight from FMCSA’s own crash data. In the agency’s pre-crash “critical event” coding, the trigger for 63 percent of trucks in fatal crashes was another vehicle, person, animal, or object in the truck’s lane or encroaching into it (a stopped vehicle, a merging car, a pedestrian). For another 24 percent, the trigger was the truck’s own movement or loss of control.
The older-but-still-gold-standard Large Truck Crash Causation Study (LTCCS) fills in the rest. The most common crash types were rear-end (23 percent), ran-off-road or out-of-lane (18 percent), same-direction sideswipes (10 percent), rollovers (9 percent), and turning conflicts (8 percent). Here’s the part that should grab every safety director: as the LTCCS Analysis Brief documents, when the truck was assigned the critical reason for the crash, roughly two-thirds traced back to driver decision or recognition errors — following too close, misjudging a gap, or not seeing the hazard in time.
Translation? A big share of these crashes are addressable through technology, training, and process. Not luck.
The five families worth your attention
Based on our typology analysis, the scenarios that carry the most risk are a manageable set. The first are rear-end crashes into stopped or slowing traffic on the open road — the everyday closing-speed conflict. Second are lane-change and merge sideswipes, the classic blind-spot encroachment. Third are roadway departures, loss of control, and rollovers, whether from drifting out of lane, taking a ramp too hot, or a load that shifts. Fourth are intersection and turning conflicts such as left turns across traffic and wide right turns over a cyclist or pedestrian. And fifth are work-zone crashes — a related but distinct problem, because work zones manufacture sudden, unexpected queues at lane closures and tapers, where the gap ahead can vanish in a heartbeat.
Work zones earn that special mention because trucks really are overrepresented there. Large trucks account for only about 10 percent of the vehicle-miles traveled on U.S. roads, per FHWA’s Highway Statistics, yet FHWA work-zone data show they were involved in roughly 30 percent of fatal work-zone crashes in 2022 (246 of them) — close to triple their share of travel, and that’s across a field that includes passenger cars, light trucks, motorcycles, and buses, not just “cars and trucks.”
What carriers can do
You don’t need to solve all five at once. Start where your own crash and near-miss data is pointing, then work down the list. For example, if you’re data shows rear-end crash are the primary risk, begin by putting technology to work on rear-end risk. Automatic emergency braking and forward collision warning are proven answers to the single most common crash type, and you don’t have to guess at the payoff. FMCSA’s TechCelerate Now program — a partnership with the American Transportation Research Institute, the Technology & Maintenance Council, and OOIDA — measured the real-world safety return of these systems across large fleets: trucks with automatic emergency braking had roughly 40 percent fewer crashes, forward collision warning cut crash rates about 30 percent, and lane departure warning — which targets the drift-and-departure crashes in our third family — reduced them about 21 percent.
You may also consider attacking the no-zones. Blind-spot detection, side and rear cameras, and disciplined mirror-scanning habits directly target lane-change and turning crashes, but the hardware only pays off when it’s paired with real coaching so drivers use it rather than tuning it out. Managing stability and speed may also pay dividends. NHTSA credits electronic stability control with preventing an estimated 40 to 56 percent of un-tripped rollover crashes and 14 percent of loss-of-control crashes, along with ramp and curve speed awareness and solid load-securement practices. These go straight at rollover and road-departure risk, so reinforce ramp and curve speed in your driver coaching.
Carriers should also coach following distance relentlessly; it’s low-cost and high-impact. Use telematics to flag hard-braking and short-following events, then have real conversations, not gotchas, with the drivers involved. Prepare drivers for work zones with route briefings, queue-warning awareness, and speed management ahead of lane closures. And don’t ignore the slow stuff. Backing and low-speed yard incidents rarely show up in the national crash data we opened with. While many aren’t even DOT-recordable, they still drain your budget and hurt people. Spotters, cameras, and a clear backing policy pay for themselves. Finally, keep the inspections honest. Brake defects showed up in nearly 30 percent of trucks in the causation study, so quality driver vehicle inspection reports, real pre- and post-trips, and a strong maintenance program are crash countermeasures, not just compliance chores.