Truckers to FMCSA: Give me more control over the clock

Mark Schremmer

Truck drivers have been clamoring for more flexibility within the hours-of-service regulations for years.

So, it’s no surprise that truckers are mostly speaking out in support of two pilot programs aimed at determining if giving drivers more control over their time will improve highway safety.

Earlier this month, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration published notices about a pair of pilot programs that will allow drivers to pause their clock and provide alternative split-sleeper options.

The Split Duty Period Pilot Program will evaluate whether drivers can safely pause their 14-hour driving window for up to three hours each day when they spend qualifying time in a non-driving status.

The Flexible Sleeper Berth Pilot Program will evaluate alternative split sleeper options that allow drivers greater flexibility in matching their off-duty time to real-world conditions, work schedules and their needs for rest. Under the pilot, participating drivers will be permitted to split that time into two periods in any combination, provided the two periods total at least 10 hours and one period includes at least five consecutive hours in the sleeper berth.

When those notices were published, the public was given 60 days to submit comments.

So far, truckers have shown support for efforts aimed at providing drivers more control over their safety.

Truck driver Maie Lee wrote in support of giving truckers more sleeper berth options.

“I think the 10-hour change will increase efficiency and control over our time,” Lee wrote. “Getting to these loads quicker will create more home time, less traffic, less fatigue from being out days because of this clock. More money can be made, and this creates safer drivers …When you’re losing money and time, you tend not to care. I was one hour from home today but couldn’t move because of this 10-hour (rule). It’s definitely needed but needs tweaking and innovation.”

Wade Reeves told FMCSA that a big part of the problem involves the electronic logging device mandate. Many truck drivers have complained that ELDs, which track truckers’ time down to the minute, are too stringent and promote speeding and other bad driving behaviors.

“Do away with your mandates on Elogs,” Reeves wrote. “They’re dangerous and the most unsafe thing you could have put in a truck and unconstitutional.”

The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association has supported giving truck drivers more flexibility and believes the key to these provisions is making sure that the truckers possess the control – and not the motor carriers.

“For years, our members have told lawmakers and FMCSA that existing hours-of-service rules are not sensible for today’s trucking industry,” OOIDA Executive Vice President Lewie Pugh said. “Hours-of-service regulations that dictate a truck driver’s work schedule are overly complex, provide little flexibility and in no way reflect the physical capabilities or limitations of individual drivers.”

Comments on FMCSA’s Split Duty Period Pilot Program can be made here, and comments on the Flexible Sleeper Berth Pilot Program can be made here. The agency will accept comments through Dec. 7.

‘White label’ ELD cheater network uncovered in NMFTA research

lex Lockie

 

Article Summary

The National Motor Freight Traffic Association discovered a network of “chameleon ELDs” registered with FMCSA that may enable hours-of-service cheating.

  • Over 1,000 ELDs are self-certified with FMCSA, raising concerns about regulatory oversight.
  • Approximately 75% of registered ELDs are white labeled, meaning they share core technology but are registered under different names.
  • FMCSA removed only 80 ELDs in the past year.
  • Some white-labeled ELDs have more than 100 identical ELDs under different names on the FMCSA’s device registry.
  • FMCSA Administrator Derek Barrs vowed to end the self-certification model. Canada’s system, with pre-registration vetting, has not experienced the same chameleon ELD problem.

New research from the National Motor Freight Traffic Association gets to the heart of a “chameleon ELD” epidemic, and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has taken notice.

NMFTA’s Chief Operating Officer Joe Ohr told Overdrive the organization has uncovered a network of hundreds of “white label” devices, or technically similar but differently named ELDs, registered with FMCSA.

The association kicked off the research after hearing from drivers and carriers like those Overdrive has reported on and in the Super Ego “chameleon carrier” network.

It’s something of an open secret that the ELD, broadly intended as a tamper-proof upgrade to paper logs, has been compromised.

How many ‘chameleon ELDs’ are out there? 

Major ELD players like Omnitracs, Samsara, Motive, Geotab and all the other big names are mostly U.S.-based and used by the biggest carriers in trucking, likewise huge numbers of small fleets and owner-operators. Ohr said those big players are on the level.

But “what was shocking,” said Ohr, “was how many ELDs were self-certified on the FMCSA website, over 1,000.”

Ohr got to wondering where all these ELDs were coming from.

“We started looking at things like country of manufacture, how many of these had parts in China?” said Ohr. “That got triggered by the whole cranes incident.”

The cranes incident referenced by Ohr refers to a Congressional investigation that found cranes used in seaports had Chinese components that could potentially act as a “Trojan horse capable of helping” China “exploit and manipulate U.S. maritime equipment and technology.”

Owner-ops have long raised similar concerns about who exactly owns ELD data and what big tech firms do with it, and when NMFTA took that thinking seriously, it did appear to expose malign foreign influence.

NMFTA used AI to look at all the documentation submitted to FMCSA on ELDs and found that some 75% of registered ELDs were “white labeled,” or products with the same core technology but registered as different brands.

“There are some valid reasons for white labeling,” said Ohr. For example, if a company creates a great ELD but isn’t interested in marketing it, another more sales-savvy firm might license the tech to market and sell its own version.

However, that’s likely not what’s going on with a lot of ELDs.

“There were companies out there with over 100 different ELDs within the FMCSA website that were the exact same,” said Ohr. Likely “there’s not a valid reason” to list the same ELD 100 times.

Think about what happened with MC numbers. They served a valid purpose for decades, but with the freight fraud boom starting in the pandemic, fraudsters registered and/or bought MCs on the private market by the hundreds. These became known as “chameleon carriers,” entities who would simply shift from one MC to the next if a safety record, scores or rating went down and they were flagged as “do not use” with brokers or shut down by FMCSA.

Chameleon ELDs share similar characteristics. FMCSA takes months of investigation and effort to remove a single ELD from its device registry, yet white labeling means there’s likely another at the ready for use by those who would abuse the hours rules and their drivers.

ELDs now abused just as readily as paper logs were 

With hundreds of white-labeled ELDs registered and only 80 total removed by FMCSA in the last year, ELD cheats remain leaps and bounds ahead of the game.

Take for example the ELD used by Hope Trans LLC during the deadly Terrell, Texas, crash on I-20.

A National Transportation Safety Board investigation into the crash found the driver was using an ELD from Ontime Logs Inc.

The “driver had been on duty for approximately 47.81 hours,” according to NTSB. FMCSA later revoked that ELD but Ontime Logs Inc. has another registered ELD in the system.

Extra Mile International, a 200-some-truck fleet accused in court documents of widespread ELD cheating, shifted ELDs several times as the devices kept getting revoked.

In a deposition, Extra Mile’s managing partner said the fleet’s ELDs were managed by a Serbian company which he also owned, but had no knowledge about.

NMFTA’s Ohr and inspectors Overdrive has interviewed about ELD cheating say there’s evidence that some operators will run two ELDs, like the old extra-logbook-under-the-seat approach operators with paper logs used to take.

“Instead of two physical books, you’ve got two digital books,” said Ohr.

Though around 75% of ELDs listed today are “white label,” Ohr said that doesn’t mean 75% of carriers or drivers cheat on their logs.

Ohr brought NMFTA’s findings to FMCSA and they’re “still trying to figure out” by reviewing inspectiondata run through the federal ERODS analysis just what percent of carriers really use the devices.

“Our goal is not to just raise red flags and not do anything,” said Ohr, who characterized FMCSA as “extremely responsive” to meeting with them. FMCSA has “done a very good job of starting to revoke ELDs” and also blocking new ELDs from entering the market.

But more needs to be done, and fast, he said. “If you’ve got one company that’s white-labeled 50 ELDs,” and one is shown to allow cheating, “you need to revoke all 50,” said Ohr.

Crackdown incoming?

Ultimately, FMCSA has long processes and rules it needs to follow to revoke ELDs, removing them from its registry.

FMCSA Administrator Derek Barrs vowed to end the self-certification model that allowed so many ELDs on the registry in the first place, and Ohr commended that idea. He pointed out that in Canada, where they do check ELD specifics before approving a device and don’t just take the maker’s word for it, there isn’t the same “chameleon ELD” problem.

With government delay, should the industry step up and blacklist the white labels?

Ohr said NMFTA is working on releasing research into its list of suspicious ELDs, and hopes to take action soon.

NMFTA issues Standard Carrier Alpha Codes, or SCAC codes used for BOLs and other documentation, and Ohr said it’s stepping up vetting for that process.

“So now when someone gets a SCAC code if they’re not Class 8, they have to go through a verification process with NMFTA,” he said. “We’re looking at expanding that for Class 8 and then offering” that data on vetted carriers to brokers.

It’s early stages yet, but the vetting around SCAC codes is where “we’re going to tie it together with this research on the white label ELDs,” said Ohr. Stay tuned for more information on NMFTA’s research.

 

When the truck talks back

How AI coaching is rewriting fleet safety and ensuring driver trust

 

Michael Freeze

PITTSBURGH — The driver’s phone buzzes and sends an audible alert. He glances down by instinct and starts to lift the handset, but before the notification can be read, a calm voice in the cab cuts in: “Please keep your eyes on the road.” With 80,000 pounds under the driver’s control, the phone goes back down. The risky behavior is corrected in the moment, before it can lead to a crash.

Scenes like this are becoming more common as fleets shift from reactive safety programs to proactive, artificial intelligence-powered driver coaching. Fleet executives and technology providers discussed how this trend is reshaping fleet safety, driver performance and overall carrier operations during The AI Summit, hosted Sept. 22-23 by American Trucking Associations’ Technology & Maintenance Council.

Panelists said the key question is how far fleets are willing to let AI reshape their culture and processes.

Real-time coaching

Dan Lambert, senior director of product management for Lytx, said AI-driven in-cab coaching systems use machine vision and telematics to interpret conditions around the vehicle and communicate with the driver immediately, marking a shift from safety programs that have historically been reactive.

“You can just tell, real-time, to the driver, ‘Hey, you know, why don’t you put your phone down,’” Lambert said. “We found in our data — when you turn on the in-cab alerts — over 90 percent of the behaviors just go away overnight.”

Shifting toward continuous, in-context feedback and away from visits to the safety office is improving in-cab behavior, said Adam Kahn, chief business development officer for Netradyne. He stressed that the timing of coaching is as important as the message.

“If I push that coaching event to the end of the day, I am still two times more effective coaching in the cab,” he said. “If I push it to the end of the week, I am 10 times more effective coaching in the cab than a week later.”

Dan Benacquista, vice president of strategic operations and planning at Modern Transportation, said the carrier focuses heavily on “precursor behaviors” such as distraction and near misses and has seen a clear difference.

“If you can conduct that coaching as close to when the behavior happens, it is going to be more effective,” he said. “After-the-fact coaching helps, but it is no substitute for prevention.”

Dissecting the data

Fleet safety teams can face paralysis by analysis when reviewing data from electronic logging systems, telematics systems, engine diagnostics and dash cameras. The sheer volume of alerts and video clips can make it difficult to identify the events that matter most. But tech providers said AI agents that continuously scan incoming data can surface trends a human analyst might miss.

“You can have a team of agents watching and monitoring in real time all the data that is flowing in,” Lambert said. “The real key there is then also bringing the human back in to decide what to do with that data.”

Benacquista said AI helps his team “distill large amounts of data into insightful actions” and “cut through the clutter,” provided fleets remain engaged and refine the prompts and guidance they give the tools.

Kahn noted AI can also connect safety outcomes to operational bottlenecks elsewhere in a fleet’s network.

“Think about a delay at the distribution center,” he said. “If there is a delay at the distribution center, what does that do to your driver? Does that delay get adjusted in their workflow, or is the delay now the burden of the driver to make up in an unsafe manner?”

By correlating loading delays, route changes and safety events, Kahn said fleets can identify when operational pressures are pushing drivers toward higher-risk behavior.

Video moves from shield to scalpel

J.S. Bouchard, co-founder and chief product officer at technology provider Isaac Instruments, said outward-facing cameras can help exonerate drivers after crashes and protect fleets from potentially costly courtroom visits. But as AI models have improved, video has become a more precise safety tool.

“What we do not want is a video of my driver with a phone in his hand. That is a liability, which I do not want,” he said. He stressed that customers not only want to know when a risky behavior occurs, they also want systems that reward quick self-correction.

“If the driver has corrected the behavior within the time that I have allowed him, that is good,” Bouchard noted. “The solutions have really evolved. It is the awareness and it is the change of behavior before the event is actually recorded.”

Context matters

That approach also can ease driver concerns about privacy and “gotcha” safety cultures. The systems continue to monitor behavior, but if a driver responds quickly to an alert, no clip is generated and the back office never sees the event.

AI also provides context for traditional telematics metrics. Kahn recalled that years ago, hard-braking events could get a driver fired regardless of context. But by reviewing video and telematics together, fleets now can assess causality and severity.

“It could be [the driver] did hard braking because someone was jaywalking,” he said. “That is a really good decision to do a hard braking, versus my eyes were diverted and I did a hard braking because I was distracted.”

Those types of examples allow fleets to use data to define and reinforce positive performance, Kahn stressed. With tens of thousands of minutes of driving recorded for each driver every month, fleets have a large sample of safe behavior they can capture, quantify and recognize.

“Having data actually supports how you model what good looks like, versus chasing what bad looks like in your organization,” he said.

The $604 Million Lesson from Lipe v. Lupus Superior

Doug Marcello

The finding everyone is missing

A Dallas County jury just handed down one of the first verdicts after Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II: A $604 million verdict in Lipe v. Lupus Superior, LLC, et al., naming freight broker C.H. Robinson.

The press coverage focused on negligent selection. The jury found C.H. Robinson negligent, right alongside the driver and the motor carrier. That’s accurate, but it’s not the finding that matters most.

What’s getting overlooked is a second, separate set of findings. The jury found the driver was C.H. Robinson’s borrowed employee, operating under its control. Those agency findings do not depend on C.H. Robinson’s own negligence causing anything, they make C.H. Robinson vicariously liable for the driver’s negligence instead.

While Justice Kavanaugh’s concurring, opinion noted brokers could defend by showing they selected a reputable trucking company in the Montgomery case, it did not address the potential agency exposure.

Why It Matters

A broker can lose the causation fight on its own negligence. However, once a jury finds operational control, the driver’s fault share can be attributed to the broker too. And Texas’s joint-and-several rule can turn that into exposure for the whole verdict. At least that is the Plaintiffs’ argument in seeking to enter judgment in the Lipe case.

By The Numbers

  • $604M: Total verdict (not yet a final judgment; post-trial motions pending, appeal anticipated)
  • 45% / 32% / 23%: Fault assigned to the driver / Motor carrier / C.H. Robinson
  • 68%: C.H. Robinson’s potential combined exposure if plaintiffs’ vicarious-liability argument holds (23% direct + 45% via the driver)
  • 50%+: The threshold that triggers joint-and-several liability under Texas law (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.013)

The Details

The jury answered three questions:

  1. The driver, the motor carrier, and C.H. Robinson were all negligent.
  2. The driver was C.H. Robinson’s borrowed employee.
  3. The driver was operating in furtherance of a mission for C.H. Robinson’s benefit and subject to its control over the details.

Plaintiffs built those findings on C.H. Robinson’s alleged authority over pickup and delivery windows, scheduling and rescheduling, late-delivery fines, and contract termination. The ordinary tools of freight brokerage were read by a jury as evidence of an employer-employee relationship.

What To Watch

  • Whether the trial court grants plaintiffs’ motion to enter judgment for the full $604M
  • C.H. Robinson’s anticipated appeal, which may test whether an independent carrier’s driver can be a broker’s borrowed employee under Texas law at all
  • Whether the plaintiffs’ firms now build “operational control” discovery into every post-Montgomery broker case

The Bottom Line

Montgomery took away the federal shield. Lipe shows what plaintiffs do next: Pair the negligence claim with an agency theory, so a narrow causation loss on one theory doesn’t end the case. Vetting carriers better defends against negligent selection. It does nothing for borrowed employees.

Railroads receive HOS exemption for ‘unplanned events’

Mark Schremmer

More than 200 motor carriers will be allowed to operate under an hours-of-service exemption requested by railroad associations.

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration announced that it was granting an exemption request from the Association of American Railroads and the American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association to allow its members to exceed hours-of-service limits so that they can respond to unplanned events.

Federal regulations prohibit drivers from operating after the 14th hour from the beginning of a work shift and from accumulating more than 60 hours of on-duty time in seven consecutive days or more than 70 hours in eight consecutive days.

The five-year exemption will allow covered drivers to respond to unplanned events that occur outside of, or extend beyond, their normal work hours. Eligible “unplanned events” are limited to incidents affecting the main track.

“The agency has analyzed the exemption renewal application and believes there is a public interest in ensuring that railroads clear blocked tracks and rights-of-way and restore service as quickly as possible,” FMCSA wrote in the notice. “The agency does not believe the requested relief would compromise safety when used occasionally to respond to unplanned events.”

When operating under the exemption, drivers:

  • May extend the 14-hour rule to no more than 17 hours
  • May not exceed 11 hours of driving time, following 10 consecutive hours off-duty
  • May extend the 60-hour/70-hour rule by no more than six hours
  • May not travel more than 300 air miles from the normal work-reporting location or terminal

The exemption is restricted to individuals employed by 231 member railroads. The 231 carriers are listed in the appendix of FMCSA’s notice.

Motor carriers must maintain a record of when the exemption is used, along with the driver’s records of duty status, supporting documents and a description of the unplanned event that prompted use of this exemption. Those records must be provided upon FMCSA’s request.

Additionally, FMCSA must be notified within five business days of any crash involving a motor carrier that was operating under the exemption.

Attorney gets jail time for role in staged crash scam targeting trucks

Land Line Media

A personal injury attorney is the latest person to be sentenced in Operation Sideswipe – an elaborate scheme that staged crashes with tractor-trailers in search of a payday.

Danny Patrick Keating Jr., 57, of New Orleans, was sentenced on Oct. 15 for conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud, arising from his role in 31 staged crashes.

In Operation Sideswipe, “slammers” were paid to participate in intentional collisions with heavy-duty trucks.

According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Louisiana, Keating admitted in 2021 to paying Damian Labeaud for 31 illegally staged tractor-trailer crashes. Keating represented 77 plaintiffs involved in the 31 crashes staged by Labeaud and 17 of the cases ended with a settlement, the U.S. Attorney’s Office said.

An indictment claimed that Keating and his clients received approximately $1.5 million from the settlements. Keating reportedly received about $358,000 in attorney’s fees.

“Keating admitted filing lawsuits in state and federal court in Louisiana, on behalf of his clients who were involved in the staged accidents,” the U.S. Attorney’s Office wrote. “The lawsuits he filed on behalf of the 77 plaintiffs fraudulently misrepresented the identity of the driver of these vehicles, fraudulently misrepresented who was at fault in the staged accidents and fraudulently claimed injuries.”

In addition, Keating used the U.S. Postal Service to mail settlement demands, and his clients provided false testimony in depositions taken in conjunction with the lawsuits he filed.

U.S. District Judge Nanette Jolivette Brown sentenced Keating to 32 months of imprisonment, followed by three years of supervised release. Keating was also ordered to pay more than $657,000 in restitution.

So far, 63 defendants have been charged in a federal probe into the staging of such collisions.

Staged Accident Fraud Prevention Act

Congress is trying to make conspiracies like Operation Sideswipe a thing of the past.

In July, Sen. Ashley Moody, R-Fla., introduced the Staged Accident Fraud Prevention Act. S5058 would make staged crashes with a commercial motor vehicle a federal crime.

There is also a House version of the bill, which was introduced by Rep. Mike Collins, R-Ga., in 2025.

The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association supports the efforts.

“Staged accidents are not victimless crimes,” OOIDA Executive Vice President Lewie Pugh said. “These are calculated, premeditated assaults that endanger lives, destroy livelihoods and compromise highway safety. To add insult to injury, criminals abuse the legal system for profit through false accusations and lawsuits, which contribute to skyrocketing insurance premiums for small trucking businesses.”