Jenny Glasscock
Hours-of-service violations are fairly easy to detect on a driver’s log. After all, ELDs are designed to keep track of drivers’ hours and will flag instances when they exceeded their allotted driving time.
However, just because the ELD system did not detect an HOS violation doesn’t mean it’s not there, concealed by log falsification.
The issue of log falsification isn’t new. It was prevalent both in the days of paper logs and still today in the ELD era. What has changed is the way drivers falsify logs: unplugging an ELD, working without being logged in or making deliveries while on personal conveyance, for example.
Log falsification isn’t something carriers should take lightly. According to FMCSA data from 2019 to 2023, “a false report of driver’s record of duty status” accounted for 4.9% of all roadside inspection violations, was the fourth most common driver violation and one of the top out-of-service violations.
While law enforcement can only see a driver’s logs from the last eight days, carriers and drivers aren’t out of the woods once this time passes. Companies are required to retain drivers’ logs for six months, which exposes them to the risk of fines or a reduction in their safety rating.
“If there comes a time when you have a crash and attorneys or law enforcement start digging into your records and find falsifications, it’s all going to come to the surface. That’s probably the worst thing that could happen when it comes to hours of service,” said Brian Runnels, vice president of safety at Reliance Partners, a Tennessee-based trucking insurance agency that aims to help motor carriers manage safety risk.
This is why it’s vital that safety departments understand how drivers falsify logs, look out for it daily and address it internally to prevent it from happening in the future. Runnels identified three valuable reports safety personnel should watch for signs of log falsification.
Reports to help catch log falsification
- Odometer report
An ELD’s odometer report provides a truck’s mileage from the beginning and end of each day.
A jump in the odometer reading from day to day means the ELD did not record those miles, which is a red flag that can be a sign the device came unplugged. Drivers can unplug the device in order to avoid being tracked by the ELD and hide the fact they drove beyond their hours-of-service limits.
“Those miles must be assigned to whoever was in the truck,” Runnels advised. “It could have been in the shop and moved around by the mechanic. But if there’s no good reason, it must be assigned back to the driver.”
- Unidentified driving report
When a driver logs out of his or her ELD and drives, but the device is still plugged in, the miles driven are still recorded. However, in most cases, the hours are not automatically added to the driver’s log.
Once the driver logs back into the system, most ELDs will ask drivers to claim any time driven as on-duty driving time. It will be considered unidentified, or unassigned, driving time if it is not claimed by the driver.
While sometimes not claiming unidentified driving time is a mistake, it’s also something drivers do when trying to conceal HOS violations; if drivers were to accept that time as on-duty drive time, it would put them over their legal work hours.
Motor carriers must retain unidentified driving records for six months, and as per the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSRs), they must “annotate the record, explaining why the time is unassigned; or, assign the record to the appropriate driver to correctly reflect the driver’s hours of service.”
Safety personnel will need to determine whether unassigned driving time should be assigned as on-duty driving time, on-duty yard move or off-duty personal conveyance. The driver then must verify it and accept it on his or her log.
- Personal conveyance report
Personal conveyance is driving done off duty for a non-working reason and does not count toward a driver’s hours of service limits. Drivers falsify logs by misusing personal conveyance, often switching from on-duty driving to personal conveyance once their available hours are up. This can be to finish delivering their current loads, advance their locations for their next pickups or even to perform other work-related moves such as driving to the repair shop.
Motor carriers should pull their fleets’ personal conveyance reports and review all annotations from drivers to ensure they are adhering to FMCSA guidelines and company policy.
Current FMCSA parameters for personal conveyance do not include specific time or distance limits, only descriptions for when it can be used, which some consider too vague. Drivers who unintentionally use personal conveyance improperly can still be dinged for false logs.
“That may have a drastic effect on a company’s safety scores because those rules are weighted so heavily. A lot of the time, drivers are also put out of service, so that is going to add points to their hours-of-service score. When you start getting a few of these falsifications, that will really wreak havoc,” Runnels said.
Carriers can enforce stricter personal conveyance guidance or turn off the function altogether, but this may not solve the root of the problem entirely: Runnels said this tends to cause an uptick in HOS violations. This could be because drivers are still met with the same scenarios that caused them to use personal conveyance in the first place.
Preventing log falsification
Whether it happens on paper or an ELD, the core reason for log falsification still remains the same: “It’s all about getting somewhere with not enough time to get there,” Runnels said.
This is an issue the industry as a whole has always grappled with but will not hold up as an excuse in the eyes of the law in roadside inspections.
Runnels recommends carriers get ahead of the issue.
“You should be telling drivers, ‘Look, we don’t put up with falsifications. If you’re going to have a problem with your hours, you need to contact us.’ Follow through with that,” Runnels said.
Dispatchers should always work with drivers to ensure they are being assigned loads they can run legally. After all, coercion of drivers to take actions that would result in violations is not only an ethical issue but is also an infraction of the FMCSRs.
Ultimately, while proactive steps should ideally help prevent falsification, Runnels advises all carriers to have a plan in place to monitor drivers’ logs and address any inconsistencies.
(Artificial intelligence detects false electronic logging device (ELD) and Hours-of-Service (HOS) log entries by cross-referencing multi-source data streams and flagging behavioral anomalies that contradict a claimed duty status.
Cross-Referencing Independent Data
- Data Fusion: AI ingests millions of data points, matching ELD digital logs against external, independent validation sources like state turnpike toll timestamps, fuel card swipes, and automated license plate reader (ALPR) or weigh-station camera captures.
-
- Telematics Mismatch: Machine learning models instantly spot discrepancies where a truck’s engine control module (ECM) or GPS telemetry registers high movement, but the driver’s log records an “off-duty” or “sleeper berth” status.
Behavioral and Pattern Anomaly Detection
- Unassigned Driving Analysis: AI flags clusters of unassigned or “ghost” driving miles—moments where the vehicle moves without an active driver login—and predicts if a driver is covertly operating the truck to bypass rest limits.
- Edit and Tamper Tracking: Algorithms monitor patterns in back-end log edits, frequency of manual status overrides, and suspicious spikes in “personal conveyance” usage to isolate intentional manipulation.
- Network & Device Fingerprinting: Advanced platforms identify anomalous real-time log alterations or sudden data corrections that happen immediately when a commercial vehicle approaches an inspection site or weigh station.)
In a case no one ever wants to publicize or even discuss, despite an all-star defendant cast and an extensive investigation into the June 19, 2021, I-65 tragedy that killed 8 children
Rob Carpenter
I’m going to start by saying that I am not an emotional person. I am well known for being one of the most emotionless people alive. This case was difficult even for me. This will be a two-part series. I first wrote about this story in February 2024. There is just so much wrong in this case, so much that was overlooked by the government and by the press. I have had the entire court file on this case for years, if you would like it and the complete NTSB report, I can provide it because it’s one of the most emotional cases I have ever worked on in highway accidents. Eight children died in flames on a rainy Alabama afternoon, and today the driver who killed them is back behind the wheel of another commercial truck. The June 19, 2021, crash on Interstate 65 near Greenville wasn’t just about excessive speed in wet conditions, as federal investigators concluded. It was the inevitable result of a broken system that allowed a driver with a questionable record to operate a commercial vehicle, and three years later, that same driver now operates his own trucking company under active federal authority.
Mamuye Ayane Takelu, the 41-year-old driver whose Freightliner pushed the Tallapoosa County Girls Ranch van into a deadly inferno, faced no criminal charges for killing eight children. Instead, he formed E&V LOGIN TRUCKING LLC in April 2024, obtained USDOT number 4233479, and returned to hauling freight on the same highways where he committed mass vehicular homicide. The system is broken. E&V Login Trucking started a year ago in GA, and since then, it has been operating an “Incomplete vehicle” with state violations, one of which is not having proper DOT door markings.
The owner, Alebachew Ademe, continues to operate several businesses to this day, including Lux Limousine, LLC, a limousine company, and has formerly operated several freight businesses.
At 2:21 that Saturday afternoon, what should have been a routine traffic slowdown became a horrific inferno that claimed 10 lives. The Tallapoosa County Girls Ranch van, carrying eight children ages 4 to 17 returning from a beach vacation, was struck and pushed into the median where it was consumed by fire along with five other vehicles. The sequence was brutal in its simplicity, an Auto Transport’s Volvo truck-tractor, traveling at 51 mph in wet conditions, plowed into stopped traffic. Moments later, Asmat Express’s Freightliner, driven by 41-year-old Mamuye Ayane Takelu, slammed into the melee at highway speeds, pushing the children’s van into the median where fuel from ruptured truck tanks ignited an inferno.
Eight children died from thermal and blunt-force trauma. Autopsy reports showed soot in all their airways, they were alive when the fire consumed them. It didn’t have to happen this way.
The man behind the wheel of the second truck represents everything wrong with America’s commercial driver licensing system. Mamuye Ayane Takelu, was operating a 40-ton commercial vehicle despite a driving record that should have disqualified him from hauling freight on American highways. Yet neither the National Transportation Safety Board nor the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration bothered to investigate the most basic questions about his background.
Takelu had been involved in three crashes during the 10 years before he killed eight children, a rate significantly higher than the industry average. He obtained his commercial driver’s license in 2016, during the peak period of refugee resettlement in Clarkston, Georgia, where his employer was based.
The NTSB investigation found that Takelu was traveling at approximately 60 to 73 mph when he encountered the traffic jam on the wet bridge. Instead of maintaining control, he veered left across lanes, struck the bridge rail, plowed through the median, and crushed the children’s van between his truck and the first commercial vehicle. Investigators found no evidence of impairment or cell phone use, but Takelu’s actions suggest either fundamental incompetence or complete disregard for basic safety principles.
Here’s what investigators never bothered to ask: What was Takelu’s immigration status at the time of the crash? How did he obtain his CDL, and were proper procedures followed? What was his English proficiency level, and could he actually understand American traffic regulations and safety requirements? Were translators used during post-crash interviews? These aren’t academic questions, they go to the heart of whether a qualified driver was operating that commercial vehicle and should ever have been placed on the highway.
Recent federal enforcement data reveals the scope of the problem investigators ignored. Violations for “Driver cannot read or speak the English language sufficiently to respond to official inquiries” have skyrocketed across multiple states. New data released by the FMCSA via Trucksafe Consulting indicates that violations and enforcement have skyrocketed.
Today, Takelu’s runs his own single-truck operation in GA. No criminal charges were filed against the driver who killed eight children. The system that enabled him to kill children continues operating exactly as it did in 2021.
Asmat Investment LLC, doing business as Asmat Express, was established in 2014 as an interstate carrier, operating 13 power units with 13 drivers according to 2017 data. Asmat reported 1.725 million miles in 2016, which is mathematically impossible for 13 trucks unless they were being driven around the clock in violation of federal hours-of-service regulations. The company provided no real driver training beyond a policy manual, had minimal safety oversight, and showed a pattern of violations that should have triggered intensive federal scrutiny.
Asmat’s location in Clarkston is the key to understanding how this tragedy became inevitable. Clarkston, dubbed “the Ellis Island of the South,” has welcomed over 40,000 refugees in the past four decades. Today, 52.9% of the city’s population is foreign-born, with residents speaking more than 60 languages within a 1.4-square-mile area. The Ethiopian community is among the largest refugee populations.
This diversity should be celebrated, but it has also created a regulatory black hole where marginal trucking operations exploit immigrant communities. Multiple sources confirm that Clarkston has become notorious for substandard CDL schools offering training in languages other than English, “fresh recruit” programs that funnel refugees into trucking through federally funded workforce schemes, and “chameleon carriers” that shut down and reopen under new names after safety violations.
The Ethiopian trucking pipeline in Clarkston represents systematic safety fraud on an industrial scale. CDL schools target Ethiopian refugees with promises of quick employment, provide training materials in Amharic despite federal English requirements, and exploit community networks to help drivers obtain licenses without proper English proficiency. Carriers like Asmat Express then exploit this pipeline for cheap labor, putting inadequately trained drivers behind the wheels of commercial vehicles.
Following the crash, FMCSA conducted a compliance review that revealed exactly what you’d expect: unsafe driving practices, failure to maintain proper records, inadequate safety management controls, and driver qualification deficiencies. The agency’s response to eight dead children was pathetically insufficient. Asmat received an Unsatisfactory safety rating on September 15, 2021, three months after killing children. The company was upgraded to Conditional status just 19 days later, after submitting a corrective action plan.
By 2023, Asmat Express had quietly ceased operations. No corporate executives faced criminal charges. The system that enabled this tragedy continues operating exactly as before.
The third layer of institutional failure involves MoLo Solutions, the Chicago-based freight brokerage that connected Asmat Express with the load they were hauling when they killed eight children. Founded in 2017, MoLo epitomized the technology-driven brokerage model that prioritizes volume over safety, connecting 70,000 carrier partners with 500 shippers while generating explosive revenue growth.
MoLo’s business model was built on utilizing technology to match freight with the most cost-effective available capacity, disregarding safety considerations. The company’s 100% year-over-year revenue growth to $274 million in 2020 came from prioritizing speed and cost over proper carrier vetting. This is the business model that puts dangerous carriers like Asmat Express in a position to kill families.
Three months after the Alabama crash, ArcBest Corporation acquired MoLo Solutions for $235 million cash. The timing is crucial because ArcBest inherited all pre-acquisition liabilities from MoLo’s broker decisions, including responsibility for the negligent vetting that connected a dangerous carrier with freight. ArcBest became legally responsible for MoLo’s failure to properly screen Asmat Express for safety qualifications and their decision to continue the business relationship despite the carrier’s problematic record.
Legal documents reveal specific failures in the broker-carrier relationship. MoLo failed to screen Asmat Express for safety qualifications properly, continued their business relationship despite the carrier’s problematic record, provided inadequate oversight of driver qualifications and carrier management, and prioritized profit over safety by focusing on volume rather than thorough vetting. When ArcBest acquired MoLo, they assumed liability for all these safety decisions and became financially accountable for the victims of pre-acquisition negligence.
This creates a perfect example of how the freight brokerage system can enable dangerous operations while major corporations profit from deadly decision-making, then shield themselves from accountability through complex corporate structures. The broker that connected a killer driver with freight faces no criminal charges, and the corporation that profited from the acquisition continues business as usual. This is exactly why TQL and CH Robinson have two separate broker liability cases at the Supreme Court.
The National Transportation Safety Board’s investigation, while technically thorough in some respects, demonstrates the agency’s institutional blindness to systemic failures that enable mass casualty trucking crashes. The NTSB correctly identified “unsafe speeds of multiple vehicles during rain, low visibility, and wet road conditions” as the probable cause. Still, this technical finding obscures the deeper institutional failures that made the tragedy inevitable.
NTSB investigators conducted a comprehensive crash reconstruction, including detailed speed calculations using video evidence and data recorders, a weather impact assessment, and an evaluation of the emergency response. They got the physics right but they completely overlooked the human and institutional factors that led to an unqualified driver being behind the wheel of a commercial vehicle in the first place.
The investigation’s critical oversights reveal either stunning incompetence or deliberate avoidance of inconvenient truths. There was no investigation of immigration status or English proficiency of the key driver, minimal examination of carrier vetting failures by brokers, no analysis of regulatory gaps that allowed marginal carriers to operate, and insufficient focus on institutional failures that enabled the tragedy.
FMCSA’s regulatory response was equally inadequate. The agency conducted standard compliance reviews and safety rating adjustments but implemented no systemic changes to carrier oversight procedures, no new broker accountability measures, and no enhanced CDL verification requirements.
Every regulatory agency involved in this investigation had strong incentives to avoid examining the immigration and language competency issues that were central to this tragedy. The result was an investigation that treated symptoms while ignoring the disease, ensuring that the system responsible for eight dead children continues operating exactly as before.
The Pruitt crash exposes multiple gaps in the current commercial vehicle safety system, but the most glaring involves the integrity of commercial driver licensing. There’s no systematic verification of immigration status during CDL application processes, inadequate English proficiency testing for commercial drivers, limited background checks for foreign-born applicants, and inconsistencies in licensing standards from state to state.
The carrier oversight system is equally broken. The FMCSA operates on a reactive enforcement model, taking action only after crashes occur. There are inadequate entry barriers for new motor carriers, limited ongoing monitoring of carrier safety performance, and insufficient penalties for safety violations. Companies like Asmat Express can operate for years with obvious safety deficiencies before anyone takes meaningful action to address them.
Broker accountability represents another massive gap. There’s limited liability for carrier selection decisions, inadequate safety screening requirements for carrier networks, corporate shield strategies that limit accountability, and profit incentives that prioritize volume over safety. Brokers can connect dangerous carriers with freight, profit from the arrangement, and face no meaningful consequences when people die.
The English proficiency requirement has been federal law since the 1930s, requiring commercial drivers to “read and speak the English language sufficiently to converse with the general public, to understand highway traffic signs and signals in the English language, to respond to official inquiries, and to make entries on reports and records.” But enforcement was essentially suspended in 2016 when the Obama administration directed inspectors not to place drivers out of service for English proficiency violations.
This enforcement gap created precisely the conditions that enabled Takelu to operate a commercial vehicle despite questionable English skills. It wasn’t until President Trump signed an executive order in 2025 requiring strict enforcement of English proficiency requirements that the system began addressing this obvious safety hazard. By then, it was too late for the eight children who died because regulators were more concerned about appearing discriminatory than protecting public safety.
Today, nearly four years after killing eight children, the key players in this tragedy have vanished into the regulatory ether. Mamuye Ayane Takelu operates a trucking company and no criminal charges were filed despite his role in a mass casualty event.
Asmat Express ceased operations by 2023, but the ownership structure was never revealed, and there’s no way to know whether the same people are operating successor companies. The pattern is classic “chameleon carrier” behavior where dangerous operators shut down after crashes and reform under new identities. Without meaningful background checks or ownership verification, nothing prevents the same people from starting new companies and exploiting new batches of inadequately trained immigrant drivers.
The broader network continues operating exactly as before. Other Clarkston carriers are still in business; the Ethiopian driver pipeline continues to channel refugees into commercial vehicles; the CDL mill system remains intact; and there was no systematic enforcement of English requirements until the 2025 policy change. The regulatory capture that enabled this tragedy persists, ensuring that more families will face similar tragedies.
Civil lawsuits were settled with sealed amounts and no admission of wrongdoing by corporate defendants. The system killed eight children and faced no meaningful consequences.
The institutional failures that killed the Tallapoosa County Girls Ranch children are symptoms of a regulatory system that has been captured by corporate interests and immigration advocacy groups that prioritize political correctness over public safety. Until federal agencies began cracking down on English proficiency violations in 2025, this system continued operating exactly as it did when it enabled Takelu to kill eight children.
The refugee-to-trucker pipeline that produced Takelu continues operating in communities across America. Federal funding programs still incentivize the recruitment of “fresh recruits,” including immigrants, refugees, and other populations that qualify for workforce development subsidies. CDL schools continue targeting immigrant communities with training programs that prioritize quick licensing over competency development. Marginal carriers continue exploiting these vulnerable populations for cheap labor while putting the American public at risk.
The brokerage system that connected dangerous carriers with freight remains fundamentally unchanged. Technology platforms continue prioritizing cost and speed over safety considerations. Corporate liability shields continue to protect major players from meaningful accountability when their decisions result in mass casualties. The economic incentives that made this tragedy profitable for multiple parties remain in place.
How many other drivers like Mamuye Ayane Takelu are currently operating commercial vehicles on American highways? How many other carriers like Asmat Express are exploiting immigrant communities while flying under the regulatory radar? How many other brokers are prioritizing profit over public safety in their carrier selection decisions? These aren’t academic questions – they’re life-and-death issues that regulators continue avoiding.
Recent high-profile crashes involving foreign-born drivers with limited English skills suggest that the problem has worsened, not improved. The system that killed eight children in Alabama continues producing similar tragedies across the country. Until there’s meaningful reform of CDL integrity, carrier oversight, and broker accountability, more families will pay the ultimate price for regulatory failure.
The death of eight children in a preventable crash represents more than a tragic accident – it’s the inevitable result of a regulatory system captured by forces that prioritize corporate profits and political correctness over public safety. From the Ethiopian immigrant driver with a questionable record to the marginal carrier with minimal oversight to the broker that prioritized volume over vetting, every institution that should have protected these children failed them.
Mamuye Ayane Takelu was the man behind the wheel, but he was enabled by a system that allowed him to operate a commercial vehicle despite obvious warning signs. Asmat Express was the carrier that employed him, but it was enabled by regulators who allowed it to operate despite minimal safety controls. MoLo Solutions was the broker that connected them with freight, but they were enabled by a system that prioritizes profit over proper vetting.
The children of Tallapoosa County Girls Ranch, ages 4 to 17, from troubled backgrounds, finally experiencing joy on a beach vacation, were burned alive because American regulatory agencies were more afraid of appearing discriminatory than of children dying in preventable crashes. Every agency involved in investigating their deaths had powerful incentives to avoid examining the core issues: immigration status, English proficiency failures, CDL mill operations, federal funding programs that incentivize dangerous driver recruitment, and corporate exploitation of immigrant communities.
The pattern of enablement is clear and continues today. Refugee resettlement programs channel immigrants into trucking without proper safety oversight. CDL mills provide licenses without adequate English training. Marginal carriers exploit cheap foreign labor. Brokers profit from connections with dangerous operators. Major corporations benefit from cheap freight rates. Regulators often overlook apparent safety violations to avoid potential claims of discrimination.
This was an instance of institutional failure at every level of the commercial trucking safety system. Eight children deserved better from the government that was supposed to protect them. Their deaths weren’t accidents, they were the predictable result of a system that values corporate convenience over children’s lives.
Until we address these systemic failures through criminal prosecution of unqualified drivers, federal investigation of CDL mill operations, corporate accountability for negligent brokers and carriers, and regulatory reform that puts American safety over foreign sensitivities, more children will die in preventable crashes. The fight for accountability and systemic reform continues in memory of eight children who were betrayed by every institution that should have kept them safe.
Tim Henry
What you need to know
- CSA is a diagnostic tool, not just a scorecard: Treating Compliance, Safety, Accountability data strictly as a report card is a costly mistake. Fleets must look past the surface rankings to uncover hidden operational, process and communication gaps before they escalate.
- Small trends predict major liability: Serious financial and legal risks rarely start with dramatic spikes. Minor, repeated violations—like localized maintenance or lighting defects—can build a documented pattern of systemic neglect that plaintiff attorneys will weaponize in the event of a crash.
- Prioritize low-threshold BASIC categories: While fleets naturally focus on their highest scores, they must pay critical attention to categories with lower intervention thresholds, such as Unsafe Driving and hours-of-service compliance, where even minor increases trigger rapid regulatory scrutiny.
- Turn data into targeted action: Use localized enforcement insights and specific violation trends to move away from generic safety training. Instead, implement location-specific ELD alerts and high-impact, one-on-one driver coaching to mitigate risks before violations occur.
Most fleets know their safety scores.
They may not check them every week, but they generally know where they stand relative to intervention thresholds. They know whether a broker has asked about them during a bid process, and they certainly know when an insurance carrier references them during renewal discussions.
But knowing the number and understanding what it actually means are two very different things. For many carriers, the Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) Safety Measurement System has become little more than a report card. Fleets monitor the numbers, react when they rise too high and otherwise leave them alone.
For years, the industry conversation around CSA has focused heavily on percentiles, thresholds and rankings. But treating CSA strictly as a scorecard may be one of the most expensive mistakes a fleet can make. Misinterpreting CSA data can influence insurance premiums, trigger deeper audits, shape litigation arguments and affect how shippers evaluate carriers during procurement. The numbers themselves are only part of the story.
CSA does not just reflect safety performance. It reveals operational weaknesses that fleets might otherwise overlook. When violations cluster, repeat or trend upward within a particular Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASIC) category, they often point to gaps in processes, oversight or communication.
An increase in Driver Fitness violations may signal weaknesses in medical certificate tracking or onboarding procedures. Repeated vehicle maintenance issues might indicate preventive maintenance processes are drifting out of sync with operational demands. Rising hours-of-service violations can sometimes reflect dispatch pressure or inconsistent log auditing.
CSA does not explicitly explain why these issues occur. But it does point to where fleets should start investigating.
Small trends can become big problems
The most expensive CSA issues rarely appear as dramatic spikes. More often, they emerge as gradual patterns that accumulate over time.
For example, say a small flatbed carrier serving regional construction projects experienced a slow increase in vehicle maintenance violations — brake adjustments, lighting defects and minor inspection findings. None of the violations individually appeared serious, and the fleet remained below intervention thresholds. But over time, those violations created a documented pattern.
How fleets should actually analyze CSA data
Fleets that treat CSA as an operational diagnostic tool can often identify issues early, before they become regulatory, legal or insurance problems.
Start by tracking your scores over time. Regularly reviewing CSA data helps fleets see whether performance is improving or trending in the wrong direction. Look closely for spikes tied to specific violations or patterns tied to certain drivers. For example, a sudden increase in lane-restriction violations might point to a particular route, driver group or operational pressure point.
Next, identify the BASIC categories that present the greatest risk. Naturally, fleets should focus on the categories with the highest scores. But they should also pay particular attention to BASICs with lower Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration intervention thresholds, such as Unsafe Driving and hours-of-service compliance. Even modest increases in these areas can attract enforcement attention.
Location analysis can also reveal important insights. Many fleets find that specific states are responsible for a disproportionate share of their violations. A deeper review may reveal that certain weigh stations, inspection locations or stretches of highway account for the majority of issues. Often, this reflects enforcement emphasis in that area—for example, a particular state focusing inspections on items like windshield wipers or lighting violations.
From there, fleets should drill down into the specific violations that are contributing to higher scores. Unsafe Driving violations, for instance, are often dominated by speeding citations. But a deeper analysis may reveal other contributors, such as seatbelt violations or following too closely. Understanding exactly what violations are driving scores allows fleets to target corrective actions more effectively.
Finally, compare performance against industry benchmarks. CSA scores are relative by design, so understanding how your fleet compares to similarly sized carriers can help put the numbers into context.
Turning CSA data into action
Once fleets understand what is driving their violations, the next step is turning that information into operational improvements.
Start by raising awareness across the organization. Everyone who can influence CSA performance—from drivers to dispatchers to maintenance teams—should understand why the scores matter and how their actions affect them. Providing regular companywide updates on safety performance can reinforce accountability and encourage improvement.
Data can also help identify drivers who may benefit from additional coaching. One-on-one meetings with drivers who disproportionately impact CSA scores can provide an opportunity to review violations, discuss expectations and reinforce best practices.
Training should also be targeted. Rather than delivering generic safety instruction, fleets can use CSA insights to focus training on the specific behaviors contributing to elevated scores.
Technology can also play a role. Fleets can create location-specific alerts delivered through electronic logging devices (ELDs) and mobile devices that notify drivers when they enter areas known for specific enforcement patterns or violation risks. For example, fleets can send real-time reminders when drivers enter corridors where speeding citations are frequently enforced, helping drivers avoid violations before they occur.
Reading CSA the right way
CSA reports alone cannot explain why violations occur. They do not reveal whether patterns stem from scheduling pressure, equipment maintenance gaps, or inconsistent compliance oversight.
Fleets that learn to read CSA data diagnostically gain something far more valuable than a better score. They gain early visibility into risks that could eventually affect insurance costs, litigation exposure, and business relationships with shippers. In an industry where safety performance increasingly influences insurance underwriting and procurement decisions, that insight can become a competitive advantage.
Ransomware, phishing, and DDoS attacks are disrupting fleets, exposing vulnerabilities in digital freight operations and supply chains.
Jenna Hume
Key takeaways
- Cyberattacks on transportation are on the rise, putting fleet systems, data, and operations at increasing risk.
- Ransomware, phishing, and DDoS attacks can halt dispatch, delay freight, and drive costly downtime.
- MFA, system updates, training, and response plans help fleets reduce cyber risk and protect operations.
Eric Van Egeren, generated by Shutterstock/AI
As technology has advanced and permeated more and more of our personal and professional lives, cybersecurity has become an increasing concern. Cybercrimes have more than doubled since 2018, according to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). From 2018 to 2024, the FBI received 5 million cyberattack complaints, with reported losses totaling $56.7 billion. The recent rise of artificial intelligence (AI) has only further complicated cybercrime.
For the trucking industry, cybercrime is an ever-growing problem, especially as more and more technology finds its way into truck cabs. Closely connected to cargo theft, cybersecurity in trucking has its own quirks and challenges. But before we get to those, let’s discuss the basics of what cybersecurity is, inside and outside of the trucking industry.
Cybersecurity basics for fleets
Cyberattacks are “any kind of malicious activity that attempts to collect, disrupt, deny, degrade, or destroy information system resources or the information itself,” according to the National Institute of Standards and Technology’s (NIST) Computer Security Resource Center.
Common types of cybercrime include phishing, ransomware, malware, data breaches, and more. The most common goal of digital criminals when targeting businesses is financial gain, though espionage and sabotage are other motivations.
Cybersecurity, therefore, is the “practice of protecting people, systems, and data from cyberattacks by using various technologies, processes, and policies,” according to IBM.
Some of the business sectors most affected by cybercrime are health care, manufacturing, financial services, small businesses, and transportation.
Why cybersecurity is critical for fleet operations and uptime
Trucking and the supply chain today are more digital than ever, with technologies such as telematics, electronic logging devices (ELDs), electronic bills of lading (eBOL), artificial intelligence (AI), autonomous vehicles (AVs), and more. Fleets can now operate more safely and efficiently with greater visibility thanks to this new technology.
But this advanced technology comes at a cost. In this new digital age, industries like trucking have become targets of digital criminals. The transportation sector saw an 186% increase in cyberattacks from June 2020 to June 2021, according to a 2021 study. Transportation ranked ninth among the top 10 most commonly targeted industries in 2025.
And when cybercrime occurs, it doesn’t just affect the industry; its effects trickle down the supply chain, eventually impacting the public and consumers. This is because cybersecurity incidents often cause unexpected downtime and delays, especially when telematics and routing technology are affected. In addition to impacting freight delivery, this results in lost revenue and tarnished reputations for trucking companies.
45582385 | Hotshotsworldwide | Dreamstime.com
Top cyber threats targeting fleets and supply chains
Like cargo theft, digital criminals are constantly adapting existing cybercrimes and creating new methods. Here are the details on the most common cybercrimes affecting trucking:
Ransomware
Ransomware is a type of malware that holds a victim’s data or devices hostage until a ransom is paid, according to IBM. Ransomware is one of the most common types of cybercrime, and it has evolved into subcategories such as double- and triple-extortion.
Double extortion is when cybercriminals threaten to leak a victim’s data online. Triple extortion involves threatening to use the stolen data to attack an organization’s customers or business partners.
Phishing
A phishing attack occurs when a cybercriminal sends an email that appears familiar but is an attempt to steal personal information, such as passwords, the National Motor Freight Traffic Association (NMFTA) states. These emails typically look like an email address for an individual or organization, with one letter, number, or punctuation mark that looks different.
DoS and DDoS attacks
Two similar cybercrime methods are Denial of Service (DoS) and Directed Denial of Service (DDoS). According to NMFTA, both types of attacks overload a system with requests and prevent access. The system shuts down when overloaded with too many requests.
When a system like this shuts down, the organization or individual cannot use it. In trucking, this could halt an entire fleet and its drivers, resulting in delays, lost revenue, spoiled products, and more, not to mention the stress this situation puts on drivers, dispatchers, managers, and others.
The difference between the two types of attacks is that DoS is system-to-system, whereas DDoS is multiple systems against one system, Fortinet states.
MITM attack
A man-in-the-middle (MITM) attack occurs when a hacker intercepts communication between two parties and modifies information.
NMFTA provides the following example of an MITM attack: “Imagine a company sends a client a message that requests they wire payment to the company’s bank account. A hacker could receive this message, replace the company’s bank account with their own, and then potentially walk away with tens of thousands of dollars.”
Brute-force attack
A brute-force attack is a type of data breach that tries every possible combination of letters, numbers, and symbols to guess the correct password eventually. This, in turn, allows a hacker to access an organization’s system.
How fleets can strengthen cybersecurity and reduce risk exposure
With so many cybercrime methods, there are also plenty of ways trucking companies can protect themselves. For every niche method of cybercrime out there, there’s a niche method of cybersecurity. But here are some broad ways fleets can protect themselves with cybersecurity.
Conduct regular audits
Conducting regular audits can help fleets identify weaknesses in their security systems before hackers find them, according to Keystone Technology Consultants. This can be done with a fleet’s IT professionals or outside cybersecurity consultants.
Use rigid authentication measures
Multifactor authentication (MFA) is another measure to protect fleet technology systems. According to Isaac Instruments, MFA requires individuals to provide more than one form of identification to log in to email or other company systems. MFA can include passwords, fingerprints, authenticator apps, email codes, etc.
Keep tech updated
When fleets fail to update their technology, they leave themselves vulnerable to new cyber threats. Promptly updating technology, and even enabling automatic updates, further protects fleet data. NMFTA found that one-third of data breaches are from vulnerabilities that technology updates would have prevented.
Train employees on cybersecurity
It may seem cliché, but proper cybersecurity awareness and training are a major way fleets can protect themselves. These training sessions shouldn’t just teach staff how to identify phishing and other scams; they should also focus on procedures for when cybercrimes do occur.
NMFTA recommends that every employee at a trucking company receive cybersecurity training, from not sending sensitive information by email to creating strong passwords.
Make cybercrime incident plans
As with cargo theft, fleets can’t just focus on prevention; they need plans in place for when cybercrimes occur. NMFTA suggests the following steps that fleets might implement as part of these plans:
- Notifying management
- Not negotiating with hackers
- Changing passwords
- Unplugging servers
- Uploading backups
Alex Lockie
This article was updated to remove mentions of PDF file formats, as they’re only used in Canada, and correct some of the discussion around which HOS violations can result in a driver being put out-of-service.
As ELD service providers cold-call trucking companies advertising ways to hide clear hours of service violations, a simple fix to the problem could be hidden in plain sight for roadside inspectors.
That’s according to Jill McBeth of Raven Transportation Safety Consulting, a company that helps motor carriers comply with HOS regs. McBeth has seen firsthand acts of ELD deception and lays the blame on non-compliant ELD service providers.
Drivers know that ELDs connect to the truck’s computer and automatically record events like driving time and stops. Drivers and fleets can edit ELD logs, like when a driver forgets to record lunch or a coffee break as off-duty time, with the driver required to approve any back-office edit, but lately a new type of ELD editing has emerged.
Overdrive reporting revealed that the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance, the multinational org charged with coming up with consistent, clear and uniform inspection protocols and the annually updated out-of-service criteria, has seen an uptick in suspiciously perfect ELD logs.
“What inspectors are finding with increased frequency are records of duty status (RODS) that are being completely altered with no indication they were edited at all,” said Jeremy Disbrow, CVSA’s Roadside Inspections Specialist. That’s contrary to what’s required of ELDs — if edits like those mentioned above are being made, the device by regulation is required to preserve those edits, and it’s a best practice for operators to annotate their records to explain edits to avoid roadside hassle.
But according to McBeth, the new type of masked alteration Disbrow noted inspectors are seeing does still leave behind indications of the edits, and if inspectors really cared to find them, they could.
Inspectors typically ask drivers to “send seven days of RODs” — that is, a seven-day logs history, she said. “And they have criteria in the technical standard for ELDs on how the devices must be able to transmit data.”
Overdrive spoke to a former inspector and CDL trainer who said most often these days, drivers transmit the HOS data via Bluetooth, a web service, or another method of digital transfer.
Those files will show any edits made to the log that the driver or carrier will then have to explain — if drivers are annotating their status changes or edits within the log, the transmitted record itself will help explain it. (For example: I forgot to switch into sleeper berth after parking.)
The new phenomenon of illegally edited ELDs doesn’t show any edits at all, but perfect adherence to the hours of service in the transmitted record.
Yet “every single device, if compliant, is programed to generate a CSV report that is identical” in structure with the same layout and headings as any other compliant device, said McBeth, referring to a “Comma Separated Values” file type that’s commonly used in spreadsheets like those produced in Microsoft Excel.
This sample of a CSV file from a non-compliant ELD shows that some of the driving time has been manually edited. It’s not easy to read, but to the trained eye, these type of edits jump out as needing further investigation, McBeth said.
The spreadsheets are required to conform to the technical standard outlined in the Code of Federal Regulations 395 subpart B section 4.8.2.1, which lays out in detail the columns, headings, and data that needs recording for an ELD to comply with the law.
Digging into the CSV file gets a little technical. McBeth shared with Overdrive sample CSV files from ELDs and pointed to a column that says if driving time was automatically recorded or not.
“You can look at this spreadsheet and in five seconds tell if that device is compliant or not compliant,” she said. Basically, the spreadsheet will show that driving time was manually edited, whereas the technical standard states an “ELD must not allow automatically recorded driving time to be shortened” unless under specific circumstances.
Hope Trans, the fleet behind the tragic Terrell, Texas, crash that killed five in June, had a long history of HOS violations, including stops with drivers that had no ELDs active. How could a company like that pass a DOT audit?
One former Hope Trans driver told local news outlet WFAA that “the company regularly altered shipping records to hide the true number of hours they had been driving.”
How exactly a non-compliant ELD company hides log edits isn’t exactly clear to McBeth, but she strongly suspects that “data manipulation is happening on a provider level. The provider that builds the app and sells it — they’re the ones doing the manipulation.”
Now, according to McBeth, inspectors are seeing suspiciously “perfect” driving logs at inspections.
“I’ve spoken to the other investigators in U.S. and Canada, and the reason [the ELD editing] gets flagged is that it’s way too perfect. There is no driver in the world that drives exactly 10 hours a day.”
This lines up with what Disbrow said previously:
“In many instances, the ELD entries that are shown to inspectors are inaccurate by hundreds or thousands of miles when compared to verified source documents, such as shipping papers, scale receipts, etc. When entire days or multiple days are completely falsified by manipulating the ELD data, inspectors have no way to identify when the driver was actually driving or resting, making it impossible to determine whether they have their required rest or available driving time.”
Of course, roadside inspectors mostly just check that the driver’s ELD shows compliance with the HOS. They do not, typically, check that the ELD complies with the technical standard. But McBeth said that with ELD providers themselves providing on-demand HOS cleanup, “roadside inspections are the key” to halting cheats among providers and fleets before the records can be falsified.
Dispatcher Hector Adrien Esquivel Rodriguez recorded a call with a company called Logbook Hub that advertises on Facebook that it can “FIX your logbook” for $30 a week. Rodriguez that featured the company telling him they only need drivers to call or text Logbook Hub, which works with several ELD providers to have driving time added to the books. The Logbook Hub representative described the company editing logs “24/7, no holidays” and manually manipulating driving time and distances. To see the video click on link below.
https://youtu.be/7aNqHwbcVrI
“If you had a section of the road where you drove 30 miles,” the service can edit the log “squeezing that driving time, we’ll make it for example 55,” the representative said.
This is the kind of log manipulation McBeth said the CSV files will show if inspectors look beyond basic HOS compliance for drivers and into the compliance of the device itself.
(The ELD cheating articles in ODDS & ENDS were not intended for readers to launch false ELD entries. I believe the ODDS & ENDS readers are the “choir” and not the “problem” motor carriers. BUT your driver may be involved in an accident with another trucking company that is a problematic motor carrier. I believe you must be aware the other truck driver and or motor carrier could be involved with ELD fraud. The articles and research are attempting to make you aware and knowledgeable of the numerous techniques used for false ELD entries. This knowledge will benefit you and your attorneys to determine if the other motor carrier’s logs presented to you during discovery are accurate.
The goal of the electronic logging device (ELD) mandate was to make driving time nearly impossible to hide. The mandate worked, in part, but the commercial pressure to keep trucks moving beyond legal driving limits did not disappear when paper logs did. Carriers and drivers adapted, exploiting gaps in the ELD system and in the regulatory framework’s enforcement capacity. ELD fraud takes several forms, ranging from opportunistic misuse of legitimate features to deliberate, carrier-directed criminal schemes.
In 2025, falsification of records of duty status was the second most-cited driver violation in CVSA inspection data, with 58,382 violations recorded. CVSA has updated its North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria to distinguish between traditional “false log” violations and false-log violations resulting from ELD tampering. For false-log violations that result from ELD tampering, new out-of-service criteria prescribe a specific violation. Drivers will also be placed out-of-service for 10 hours if records have been so thoroughly altered that inspectors cannot determine the last rest period.
What AI does is to alter the ELD output file which is a computer file created or saved by a program, device, or process to store the results, data, or logs. This file includes a header segment and variable-length segments for driver activity, vehicle use, and events. The file segments and data content are:
- Header Segment: Contains non-varying administrative info like driver name, username, license details, motor carrier name, USDOT number, and active vehicle/co-driver identifiers.
- Driver Records: Tracks individual driver identification, authenticated users, and specific duty status changes (off-duty, sleeper berth, driving, on-duty).
- Vehicle & Engine Data: Records commercial motor vehicle (CMV) details, power unit number, VIN, accumulated vehicle miles, and engine hours.
- Event Activity Logs: Captures date, time, and geographic location stamps for all recorded events and changes in driving or power status.
- System & Diagnostic Files: Lists ELD login/logout sessions, malfunction indicators, data diagnostic event records, and any activity assigned to an unidentified driver.
This is why MCSAP officers when checking for false ELD entries will (or should) immediately take photographs of the ELD screen and supporting documents before the driver has an opportunity to place a call to the illegal entity (using AI) to alter the ELD entries making them appear legal.)
Ryan Witkowski
Truckers, give yourselves a pat on the back. Over 94% of all drivers inspected during this year’s International Roadcheck did not have any out-of-service violations.
Conducted annually by the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance, International Roadcheck is a 72-hour high-visibility, high-volume commercial motor vehicle inspection and enforcement initiative. This year’s event took place May 12-14.
On Tuesday, Aug. 25, CVSA released the results from the 2026 International Roadcheck. Over the three-day event, inspectors conducted 54,575 inspections of commercial motor vehicles and drivers across North America. From those inspections, 81% of vehicles and 94.2% of drivers did not have out-of-service violations.
Conversely, 10,350 trucks (19%) and 3,184 drivers (5.8%) were placed out of service due to one or more violations. According to CVSA, a commercial motor vehicle or driver is placed out of service “when an inspector finds a violation that is serious enough to make continued operation unsafe.” If that’s the case, the vehicle or driver must remain off the road until the violation has been addressed or brought into compliance.
Each year, the agency highlights certain aspects of roadside inspections during International Roadcheck. For this year’s event, inspectors were focusing on ELD tampering, falsification or manipulation during driver inspections and cargo securement during vehicle inspections.
When it comes to vehicle inspections, the top violation was with brake systems, with 3,379 violations recorded for an out-of-service rate of 24.3%. Other violations making up the top five include:
- Tires: 2,914 violations, 20.9% OOS rate
- 20% Defective Brakes: 2,072 violations, 14.9% OOS rate
- Cargo Securement: 1,724 violations, 12.4% OOS rate
- Lights: 1,659 violations, 11.9% OOS rate
As far as drivers go, inspectors identified 3,806 total driver out-of-service violations in the U.S. and 163 in Canada, for a combined total of 3,969 driver out-of-service violations during International Roadcheck.
The number one violation for drivers was having no medical card, with 1,072 drivers being sidelined for that. Other issues rounding out the top five included:
- Hours of service: 929 violations
- No CDL: 620 violations
- English proficiency: 361 violations
- False record of duty status: 266 violations
The agency said that CVSA decals – which are given to CMVs without any critical vehicle inspection violations – were applied to 11,880 power units and 5,751 trailers during International Roadcheck. In total, 17,680 decals were distributed throughout North America during the 72-hour event.
One overwhelmingly positive result came in terms of seat belt usage. During the event, just 1.25% of all drivers inspected were not wearing a seat belt, resulting in a total of 667 seat belt violations being issued during this year’s International Roadcheck.
According to CVSA, roughly 13 vehicles per minute were inspected throughout North America during the event.