NEWS & REPORTS

Take More Cases to Trial: Data Reveals Missed Opportunities

Aug 23, 2025 | Reports

Doug Marcello

 

Why It Matters

Trucking companies are overpaying by settling cases that could be won at trial, creating a cycle of inflated claims and emboldening plaintiff attorneys.

 

By The Numbers

Settlement vs. trial outcomes tell a stark story:

  • 50.3% of settled cases exceeded $500,000, compared to only 31.5% of cases that went to verdict (American Transportation Research Institute study)
  • Only 1.8% of cases went to trial over the past decade, while 98.2% were settled (Sedgwick report)

When cases did go to trial:

  • Defendants won 75.4% of the time
  • Plaintiffs prevailed in 21.7% of cases
  • 2.9% went to appeal

 

The Problem

Overpayment: Companies are leaving money on the table by settling winnable cases.

 

Market distortion: Settlement amounts are based on what other cases settle for – not what juries actually award. This creates artificial inflation in claim values.

 

Emboldening plaintiffs: Aggressive attorneys see every claim as profitable, regardless of merit, knowing companies will likely settle.

 

What’s driving excessive settlements?

  • Nuclear verdicts: The existential threat of massive judgments makes companies risk-averse
  • Attorney inexperience: Few defense lawyers actively try cases anymore, breeding insecurity that leads to settlement
  • Business calculations: It’s often cheaper to pay than fight, but this feeds the cycle

 

The Solution

Be strategic: Nuclear verdict cases are usually identifiable – avoid those risks. But cases with good facts, limited damages, and favorable venues are trial-worthy.

 

Take calculated risks: Force plaintiffs to prove their cases before juries. Low-risk cases should go to trial more often.

 

Choose the right lawyers: Hire attorneys with actual trial experience who are willing to take cases to verdict.

 

The Bottom Line

Current settlement practices are driving spiraling costs. Strategic use of trials could significantly reduce payouts and discourage frivolous claims.

About the Author

NEWS & REPORTS

Why Commercial Motor Vehicle Enforcement Matters

A Perspective from Roadside by Jake Elovirta, Director of Enforcement Programs, Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA)   Introduction Commercial Motor Vehicle (CMV) enforcement agencies operate on a straightforward premise that a fully loaded tractor-trailer...

What to do if your ELD stops working

Ryan Witkowski Like it or not, electronic logging devices are a necessary evil for most drivers. While their use may be mandated, technology isn’t always as helpful or reliable as we’d like. So, what do you do when your ELD malfunctions? OOIDA’s Compliance Department...

Truckers to FMCSA: Give me more control over the clock

Mark Schremmer Truck drivers have been clamoring for more flexibility within the hours-of-service regulations for years. So, it’s no surprise that truckers are mostly speaking out in support of two pilot programs aimed at determining if giving drivers more control...

‘White label’ ELD cheater network uncovered in NMFTA research

lex Lockie   Article Summary The National Motor Freight Traffic Association discovered a network of "chameleon ELDs" registered with FMCSA that may enable hours-of-service cheating. Over 1,000 ELDs are self-certified with FMCSA, raising concerns about regulatory...

When the truck talks back

How AI coaching is rewriting fleet safety and ensuring driver trust   Michael Freeze PITTSBURGH — The driver’s phone buzzes and sends an audible alert. He glances down by instinct and starts to lift the handset, but before the notification can be read, a calm...

CATEGORIES