NEWS & REPORTS

SEDGWICK NAMED IT. THE DATA CONFIRMS IT. THE INDUSTRY NEEDS TO ACT ON IT.

Aug 8, 2026 | Articles

Doug Marcello

That phrase appears in Sedgwick’s Summer 2026 liability litigation report — attributed originally to the Institute for Legal Reform — to describe what nuclear verdicts produce beyond the courtroom: a perception of risk that inflates settlement values in cases.

Two data sources now converge on the same problem.

WHAT THE VERDICT DATA ACTUALLY SHOWS

The prior Sedgwick report captured a decade of closed litigation outcomes. Of the cases that reached a verdict — already only 1.8% of the total — 75.4% came in below the last settlement offer extended before trial. Only 21.7% exceeded the pre-trial offer.

ATRI’s analysis of trucking cases found that approximately 50.3% of settled cases had awards exceeding $500,000. Only 31.5% of verdict cases reached that level. Defendants who settled paid at high levels more often than defendants who went to trial.

The defense industry behaves as if trial is the dangerous option. The data says otherwise.

 

THE 2026 SEDGWICK DATA ON WHERE SEVERITY IS BEING CREATED

Sedgwick’s 2026 report — drawn from Sedgwick’s own claims portfolio — adds a severity trajectory that makes the problem concrete:

  • Verdict severity grew approximately 3.7% annually over the last five years in Sedgwick’s data — roughly in line with inflation.
  • Settlement severity grew 12.6% annually over the same period — more than three times the verdict rate.
  • In 2025, only 1.25% of bodily injury litigated cases in Sedgwick’s portfolio went to verdict — down from 12% in 2016.
  • Time-limited demands in auto cases have grown 45% annually since 2021 in Sedgwick’s data.

Sedgwick’s conclusion: “The data indicates that severity escalation is being driven more by voluntary settlements than by jury verdicts.” And: “defense decision-making appears to be shaped by fear and distorted perceptions of jury behavior rather than empirical trial outcomes.”

THE TORT REFORM PIECE

Nuclear fallout settlements are partly a market distortion created by nuclear verdict fear — which means the tort reform agenda that reduces nuclear verdicts also matters to the settlement problem.

But reform operates at the macro level. It moderates the conditions. It does not resolve the individual settlement decision.

That resolution requires the defense community to develop and use the willingness to try defensible cases — backed by the data showing that trial outcomes are more favorable to defendants than the settlement calculus assumes. Credible trial readiness changes negotiation dynamics. Sedgwick says so directly in its conclusion.

THE QUESTION

Before every settlement: are we paying what this case is worth — or what we are afraid a jury might do?

The gap between those two numbers is, based on Sedgwick’s claims data. That is the cost of fear.

 

About the Author

NEWS & REPORTS

121 ELDs Removed from FMCSA Registered Devices List

FMCSA has removed 121 ELDs from the list of Registered Electronic Logging Devices (ELDs). Motor carriers and drivers using any of the revoked ELDs below have 60 days to replace them with compliant ELDs. On November 12, 2026, FMCSA removed the following ELDs from the...

Why Commercial Motor Vehicle Enforcement Matters

A Perspective from Roadside by Jake Elovirta, Director of Enforcement Programs, Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA)   Introduction Commercial Motor Vehicle (CMV) enforcement agencies operate on a straightforward premise that a fully loaded tractor-trailer...

What to do if your ELD stops working

Ryan Witkowski Like it or not, electronic logging devices are a necessary evil for most drivers. While their use may be mandated, technology isn’t always as helpful or reliable as we’d like. So, what do you do when your ELD malfunctions? OOIDA’s Compliance Department...

Truckers to FMCSA: Give me more control over the clock

Mark Schremmer Truck drivers have been clamoring for more flexibility within the hours-of-service regulations for years. So, it’s no surprise that truckers are mostly speaking out in support of two pilot programs aimed at determining if giving drivers more control...

‘White label’ ELD cheater network uncovered in NMFTA research

lex Lockie   Article Summary The National Motor Freight Traffic Association discovered a network of "chameleon ELDs" registered with FMCSA that may enable hours-of-service cheating. Over 1,000 ELDs are self-certified with FMCSA, raising concerns about regulatory...

CATEGORIES