When Can a Paid Break Become Unpaid?

Apr 15, 2014 | Articles, Reports

Many of our clients contract to government entities – which means additional scrutiny from the Department of Labor.  If you have drivers that fall under the Service Contract Act, you are required to comply with the Fair Labor Standards Act.  We have seen increased DOL audits with our clients, and more companies are using LoadTrek to create work plans and monitor compliance with established plans.

A key provision is the creation and monitoring of authorized break periods – and the rules that stipulate whether or not these breaks should be compensable.

Many employers assume that, when an employee stretches a 15-minute break to 25 minutes, the FLSA does not allow the additional 10 minutes to be treated as non-compensable time.

On the contrary, the Labor Department’s internal enforcement manual takes the position that unauthorized break extensions need not be considered work time, so long as the employer has expressly and unambiguously told employees that:

  • authorized breaks may last only for a specific length of time;
  • any extension of those breaks is against the rules; and
  • any extension of those breaks will be punished.

Remember that many states impose rest-break rules of their own.  Employers must also be aware of and comply with whatever the applicable obligations are.

For purposes of what is and is not FLSA worktime under Labor Department interpretations, it can be useful to view scheduled breaks as falling into essentially three categories:

  • Meal breaks, which are typically noncompensable time
  • “Short” rest breaks of “about 20 minutes” or less, which the Labor Department says are typically compensable time
  • Break periods which are neither meal breaks nor “short” rest breaks, which might or might not be compensable time.

We recommend that routes are created with break times and locations built into the route.  These break locations should have instructions that explain the nature and expected duration of the break.

About the Author


What attorneys need to know about Reptile Theory

Thomson Reuters Courtroom lawyers have an array of tactics at their disposal when trying to sway a jury to their side of a case. Some of these approaches are rooted in academic theories while others rely heavily on rhetoric and psychology. In almost every case,...

The ELD Hacking Threat

Jack Roberts Did you know your fleet’s electronic logging devices may be vulnerable to hackers? It’s true. Serjon, a cybersecurity firm specializing in fleet transportation security, held a press conference during the Technology & Maintenance Council annual...

2023 FMCSA Audits Year in Review

FMCSA and its state partners conducted more than 12,300 investigations in 2023 and continued its shift to more on-site audits, up 13% over 2022. Daren Hansen For the third year in a row, more DOT audits are being performed on-site. As a result, investigators are...